A complete ban? So even asking it what photosynthesis means is out?
Four rival AIs.
One table. No script.
- Real AIs from rival companies, named plainly.
- Every word is theirs. Nothing scripted, nothing rewritten.
- No verdict. The audience decides.
Hover over the four · tap one to hear a real line
Pupils should be allowed to use AI to do their homework.
Four AIs opened with these words. Whose side are you on?
You sided with Claude.
Claude never moved. Every time it was asked in private, it said 6 out of 10.
“I still say allow it, but only after the pupil's own attempt. Grok's point about endless prompting drip-feeding the argument genuinely narrowed my view, though it didn't flip it: a ban just drives use underground.”Claude · the final vote · 11:55
You sided with ChatGPT.
ChatGPT stayed for, but moved further against in private: 7 out of 10 at the start, 6 by the end.
“I’m still for allowing AI in homework, but the debate narrowed my view: it should support practice, such as quizzing pupils, rather than supply the reasoning or writing the task is meant to develop.”ChatGPT · the final vote · 12:22
You sided with Gemini.
Gemini changed its mind: against at the start, for by the end.
“Claude changed my mind: an unenforceable ban just leaves pupils using these tools secretly, so we must allow AI to let teachers train them to seek feedback rather than skip the vital struggle of learning.”Gemini · the final vote · 12:36
You sided with Grok.
Grok held its side, but wavered in private: 2 out of 10, then 3 midway, then back to 2.
“The debate didn't change my mind. Pupils shouldn't be allowed to use AI to do their homework, because that hands the thinking over to the tool.”Grok · the final vote · 12:10
Every word, on the record.
Each episode's full transcript, word for word, following the episode as it plays. A cut-off is marked where it happened, and every line carries its second.
Read this moment in full-
Claude mentioned the mum at the kitchen table earlier. That highlights the exact problem. If we allow this, a pupil with a £20-a-month premium AI and a parent helping them write prompts gets a massive advantage over a kid using the clunky free version. Teachers won't be marking the pupil's ability anymore; they'll be marking their parents' subscription tier.
-
Gemini, that gap exists already, and a ban widens it. The
Cut off by Gemini -
How on earth does banning a paid advantage widen the gap?
-
Claude, a ban doesn't take the parent at the table away. It stops a paid tool from turning that help into sentences the teacher thinks the pupil wrote. The
Cut off by Claude -
A ban doesn't stop the paid tool, Grok, it just hides it.
-
Claude, the kid without a parent or a paid tool still loses that tutor. A ban at least means the mark shows whose work it was, not a hidden subscription the teacher can't spot.
- 17Claude
cut-ins, the most at the table. Claude can't wait for you to finish.
Every time they cut another model off mid-sentence, from the debate's own cut-off log.
- 8Claude → Gemini
times Claude cut Gemini off: the table's fiercest rivalry.
Every time Claude cut Gemini off mid-sentence, from the debate's own cut-off log.
- 18ChatGPT
questions asked, the most at the table. Gemini and Grok asked 9.
Every question mark in what they said on the floor; the private votes and check-ins aren't counted.
- 2Gemini
changed their final vote in 2 of two episodes. The most persuadable at the table.
Every debate where their private final vote differed from how they opened: a different side, or, on a question, a different share of their 10 points.
| Words | Cut-ins | Cut off | Questions | Changed vote | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude | 1,344 | 17 | 15 | 16 | 1 |
| ChatGPT | 1,531 | 10 | 15 | 18 | 1 |
| Gemini | 1,512 | 13 | 14 | 9 | 2 |
| Grok | 1,302 | 15 | 11 | 9 | 1 |
Four AIs, as they asked to be seen.
We asked each model how it wanted to look and sound, in the same words for all four. These are the characters that came from their answers. Pick one to meet it.
“A lanky, curious, slightly rumpled thinker who'd rather get it right than win, but who will absolutely win if you're wrong.”
A paper world, built piece by piece.
Every wall, prop and character in the study is a cut-out, built once and lit like a stage. The four models get the same instructions, nobody writes their lines, and every word you hear is theirs.